Project Classification
Descriptions courtsey of www.ysf.ca
1. Project Categories
1.1 Elementary (grade 3 to 6)
1.2 Junior (grade 7 and 8)
1.3 Intermediate (grade 9 and 10)
1.4 Senior (grade 11, 12)
Group projects may be accepted with a maximum of two patricipants. Projects are to be registerd in the age level of the oldest partner in a group.
2 Project Divisions
2.1 Biotechnology
a) A biotechnology project involves the application of knowledge of biological systems
to solve a problem, create a product or provide a service. Biotechnology projects
generally fall into one of four fields: crop development, animal science, genomics,
and microbials.
(a) Crop development projects focus on plants that are involved in agricultural,
horticultural or silvicultural (forestry) production. Projects in this area may
investigate problems of herbicide tolerance, spacing, cultivation, irrigation, effect
of soil variation, hybridization, etc.
(b) Animal science projects pertain to animals involved in agriculture and
aquaculture, those domesticated as pets, or for sport, as well as projects where
humans are participating in wild animals’ lives, perhaps through habitat
revitalization, population management, or harvesting. Possible topics include
enhancement of animal production, reproductive technologies, genetics and
transgenics, animal health, housing, training and interactions. Most animal
science projects will be of the study type. Experiments on vertebrates by preuniversity
students demand careful planning and pre-authorization and must
satisfy the YSF Canada rules that govern the use of animals.
(c) Genomics projects focus on deciphering and understanding the genetic
information content of an organism. Genomics differs from classical biological
research in its large scale, broad scope and intense reliance on data collection,
analysis and information technology (bioinformatics). Proteomics, the study of
proteins - their location, structure and function, is part of the wider study of
genomics.
(d) Microbial projects consider how microbials affect productivity in agriculture,
horticulture and forestry. Possible topics include plant growth-promoting
rhizobacteria, biological weed and fungal control, bio-fuel cells, etc.
b) Projects that focus on the acquisition of knowledge about how something lives are
categorized as Life Science, not Biotechnology. The distinction is similar to that
between Physical Science projects and Engineering projects; in both cases projects
in the latter division deal with an application of knowledge to solve a problem. Often
the discriminating factor is in the finalist’s conceptualization of the project. There will
be situations where the choice is not clear.
2.2 Earth and Environmental Sciences
a) An earth and environmental sciences project focuses on a topic relating to planetary
processes, the relationship of organisms to those processes, or the relationships
between or among organisms.
b) Projects in this division can include issues in any of the following scientific
disciplines: geology, mineralogy, physiography, oceanography, limnology,
climatology, seismology, geography, and ecology. Earth and environmental science
includes the study of pollution, its sources and its control. It can also involve studies
of biotic and/or abiotic factors in an environment, where such studies enhance our
understanding of biological relationships and abiotic cycles.
c) Studies dealing with resource management or sustainable development would
usually fall into this category. Examples of such studies might include
capture/recapture studies for estimation of population densities, determination of
bioproductivity in a specific ecosystem or niche, studies of plate tectonics and
examination of mineral cycles (e.g., salt mills in the oceans).
2.3 Engineering and Computing Sciences
a) An engineering or computing sciences project applies physical knowledge to solve a
problem or achieve a purpose, or deals with computing or an innovative software or
hardware design.
b) Although a complete engineering project will include an outline of the need, the
development of the innovation and some work on introducing the innovation to the
community, many projects focus on just the development phase.
c) Engineering projects normally focus on a new process, or a new product. A study of
Bernoulli’s principle would be Physical Science, while the application of such a
principle to improved aerodynamics and wing design would be engineering.
d) Computing science projects are applied science and technology projects that
concentrate primarily on the development of computer equipment or programs. They
focus on computers, their languages, their software, databases and their function.
Projects using computers to store and handle data are normally entered in the
division suggested by the nature of the data. However, if the project is more focused
on technique using the computer to accomplish this task and the data are of
secondary significance, the project should be entered in this division.
2.4 Health Sciences
a) A health sciences project examines some biomedical and/or clinical aspect of human
life or lifestyle and its translation into improved health for humans, or more effective
health services and products. Projects related to the health of specific populations,
societal and cultural dimensions of health, and environmental influences on health
are also included in this division.
b) Health sciences projects include those related to human aging, genetics, cancer
research, musculoskeletal health, arthritis, circulatory and respiratory health,
nutrition, neurosciences, mental health, psychology, metabolism, human
development, infection and immunology.
c) Projects involving animal research that have a direct application to humans are
included in this division.
2.5 Life Sciences
a) A life science project examines some aspect of the life or lifestyle of a non-human
organism.
b) Life science projects include botany and zoology, as well as psychology and
kinesiology of non-human organisms. Examining plant growth or animal behaviour
are examples of life science. Some phenomena, such as digestion, involve both life
science and physical science. The selection of division will spend on whether the
young scientist’s intent was to study the chemistry of the process, or the role of the
process in the life of the animal (eating, production of enzymes, handling of wastes,
etc.)
2.6 Physical and Mathematical Sciences
a) A physical and mathematical sciences project studies abiotic phenomenon to
understand the relation between identified factors, perhaps including a cause and
effect relationship, or the use of mathematical models or mathematics to solve
theoretical problems.
b) Physical science projects include fields such as physics, and chemistry and
astronomy. Comparison testing of products is included in this division.
c) Some projects entered as physical science may be more accurately entered as
engineering. For example, experimenting to find "Which materials best absorb oil?" is
physical science, though there is an implied application of the results. On the other
hand, for a project investigating, "Which materials best absorb oil from an oil spill?"
the emphasis is on an application and would normally be classified as engineering.
d) Mathematical science projects seek to demonstrate applications of mathematics (i.e.
the search for a mathematical model) or to solve a theoretical problem. For example,
in attempting to predict the shape of cacti, the use of mathematics would be central
to the project. The problem provides a context for the exploration of pattern and the
search for a mathematical model. Some areas of investigation in this category
include algorithms, operational research (applications of mathematical and
computing science to solve planning or operational problems), and statistics.
2.7 Interdisciplinary Projects
a) Many projects are interdisciplinary and therefore, seem to fit into more than one
division. The finalist(s) must choose only one of the divisions. This decision should
be based on the subject area in which the finalist is most knowledgeable and best
able to communicate their knowledge to the judge. Through the interview process,
judges look for both depth and breadth in all projects and are encouraged to consult
with other judges when a project incorporates another field outside their area of
expertise.
.
3 Project Types
3.1 The judging of "scientific thought" requires special attention since a variety of different
types of projects exist. The most common types of science fair projects are experiments,
studies and innovations. Projects of each type are equally capable of winning top awards
at the fair, providing they meet the necessary criteria.
3.2 Experiment
a) This is traditionally the most common type of science fair project. A winning exhibit of
this type should involve an original scientific experiment to test a specific hypothesis
in which the young scientist recognizes and controls all significant competing
variables and demonstrates excellent collection, analysis, and presentation of data.
The judge should also realize that it is not regarded as essential that any significant
positive findings result from the project. It must be recognized that it is the design
rather than the results that are most important.
3.3 Innovation
a) A project of this type would involve the development and evaluation of new devices,
models, techniques or approaches in fields such as technology, engineering, or
computers (both software and hardware). A winning project should integrate several
technologies, inventions, or designs and construct an original innovative
technological system that will have commercial application and/or human benefit. It
must demonstrate how the innovation was designed or developed on the basis of a
sound understanding of the scientific, engineering, or technological principles
involved.
3.4 Study
a) This type of project involves the collection and analysis of data from other sources to
reveal evidence of a fact, situation, or pattern of scientific interest. This could include
a study of cause and effect relationships or theoretical investigations of scientific
data. A winning exhibit in this area must be able to demonstrate that the methods
used to obtain the original data involved sound scientific techniques and controls,
and demonstrate insightful analysis.